{"format":1,"version":"de638baa93c435ff","methodVersion":"outcomes@1","domain":{"id":"housing-assistance","label":"Housing assistance","description":"HUD programs (Assistance Listings 14.xxx) and USDA rural housing (10.405–10.448): vouchers, rental assistance, public housing, community development; loans at subsidy cost. Mortgage insurance is left out.","measure":"obligations","shockFloorPerResident":100,"caveat":"Most housing money pays rents of existing homes; only part of it builds new ones.","sources":["usaspending-assistance"],"fiscalYears":[{"year":2021,"complete":true},{"year":2022,"complete":true},{"year":2023,"complete":true},{"year":2024,"complete":true},{"year":2025,"complete":true},{"year":2026,"complete":false},{"year":2027,"complete":false}]},"outcome":{"key":"typical_home_value","label":"Typical home value","shortLabel":"Home value (Zillow)","description":"Zillow Home Value Index: value of a typical home (middle third of the market), seasonally adjusted. Context: affordability is scored separately.","unit":"usd","decimals":0,"direction":"neutral","comparison":"percent","annualization":"december","source":"zillow","years":{"last":2025,"first":2009}},"pairing":{"domain":"housing-assistance","outcome":"typical_home_value","rationale":"Housing programs change demand for and supply of homes.","lagYears":{"min":1,"max":2},"headlineYear":1,"caveat":"Home values follow interest rates and regional markets; housing aid is small relative to the market."},"finding":{"domain":"housing-assistance","outcome":"typical_home_value","comparison":"percent","headlineYear":1,"strength":"unreliable","direction":null,"shocks":73,"result":{"estimate":-1.024834,"ciLow":-2.447486,"ciHigh":0.389861},"placebo":{"estimate":1.608478,"ciLow":0.115199,"ciHigh":3.151535},"unmatched":1},"eventStudy":[{"relativeYear":-3,"shocks":73,"estimate":-0.194934,"ciLow":-0.685778,"ciHigh":0.290269,"meanShockChange":-17.719395,"meanControlsChange":-17.524461},{"relativeYear":-2,"shocks":73,"estimate":-0.381389,"ciLow":-0.984562,"ciHigh":0.193865,"meanShockChange":-7.686266,"meanControlsChange":-7.304877},{"relativeYear":-1,"shocks":73,"estimate":0,"ciLow":null,"ciHigh":null,"meanShockChange":0,"meanControlsChange":0},{"relativeYear":0,"shocks":73,"estimate":-0.826715,"ciLow":-1.841168,"ciHigh":0.273302,"meanShockChange":2.932973,"meanControlsChange":3.759687},{"relativeYear":1,"shocks":73,"estimate":-1.024834,"ciLow":-2.447486,"ciHigh":0.389861,"meanShockChange":6.088261,"meanControlsChange":7.113095},{"relativeYear":2,"shocks":53,"estimate":-2.31163,"ciLow":-4.836904,"ciHigh":0.124889,"meanShockChange":6.862842,"meanControlsChange":9.174472}],"placebo":[{"relativeYear":0,"shocks":71,"estimate":0.719765,"ciLow":0.120347,"ciHigh":1.327383,"meanShockChange":11.984841,"meanControlsChange":11.265076},{"relativeYear":1,"shocks":71,"estimate":1.608478,"ciLow":0.115199,"ciHigh":3.151535,"meanShockChange":26.469908,"meanControlsChange":24.861429}],"shocks":[{"geoid":"17141","name":"Ogle County, IL","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":791.969064,"baselinePerResident":54.747431,"ratio":14.465867,"increasePerResident":737.221633,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-0.762554,"shockChange":6.738008,"controlsMeanChange":7.500563,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/17141"},{"geoid":"21005","name":"Anderson County, KY","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":708.803963,"baselinePerResident":3.469473,"ratio":204.297275,"increasePerResident":705.33449,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":1.330378,"shockChange":11.920283,"controlsMeanChange":10.589905,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/21005"},{"geoid":"40111","name":"Okmulgee County, OK","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":1132.636265,"baselinePerResident":526.873127,"ratio":2.149732,"increasePerResident":605.763138,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":1.902749,"shockChange":14.903673,"controlsMeanChange":13.000924,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/40111"},{"geoid":"02110","name":"Juneau City and Borough, AK","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":981.238748,"baselinePerResident":420.322102,"ratio":2.334492,"increasePerResident":560.916645,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":5.463549,"shockChange":3.61877,"controlsMeanChange":-1.84478,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/02110"},{"geoid":"46065","name":"Hughes County, SD","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":624.01015,"baselinePerResident":129.923088,"ratio":4.80292,"increasePerResident":494.087062,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-4.237103,"shockChange":3.149127,"controlsMeanChange":7.38623,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/46065"},{"geoid":"35055","name":"Taos County, NM","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":679.514302,"baselinePerResident":219.00914,"ratio":3.102676,"increasePerResident":460.505162,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-14.006776,"shockChange":-9.414979,"controlsMeanChange":4.591797,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/35055"},{"geoid":"41013","name":"Crook County, OR","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":455.327357,"baselinePerResident":7.612833,"ratio":59.810502,"increasePerResident":447.714524,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-0.874111,"shockChange":1.588434,"controlsMeanChange":2.462545,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/41013"},{"geoid":"12115","name":"Sarasota County, FL","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":525.054153,"baselinePerResident":92.248483,"ratio":5.691738,"increasePerResident":432.80567,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-8.60692,"shockChange":-15.091735,"controlsMeanChange":-6.484815,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/12115"},{"geoid":"53049","name":"Pacific County, WA","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":458.60586,"baselinePerResident":90.904166,"ratio":5.044938,"increasePerResident":367.701694,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-2.582844,"shockChange":1.689513,"controlsMeanChange":4.272357,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/53049"},{"geoid":"47007","name":"Bledsoe County, TN","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":381.713781,"baselinePerResident":50.834493,"ratio":7.508952,"increasePerResident":330.879288,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-5.246985,"shockChange":6.225164,"controlsMeanChange":11.472148,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/47007"},{"geoid":"21159","name":"Martin County, KY","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":496.730699,"baselinePerResident":172.775967,"ratio":2.874999,"increasePerResident":323.954732,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-13.184681,"shockChange":-3.388405,"controlsMeanChange":9.796276,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/21159"},{"geoid":"26089","name":"Leelanau County, MI","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":362.891888,"baselinePerResident":55.620201,"ratio":6.524462,"increasePerResident":307.271688,"controls":3,"headline":{"difference":-5.068469,"shockChange":11.843086,"controlsMeanChange":16.911555,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/26089"},{"geoid":"39115","name":"Morgan County, OH","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":309.179956,"baselinePerResident":3.478677,"ratio":88.878596,"increasePerResident":305.701279,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-2.015468,"shockChange":8.166143,"controlsMeanChange":10.18161,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/39115"},{"geoid":"16009","name":"Benewah County, ID","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":476.620923,"baselinePerResident":173.347988,"ratio":2.749504,"increasePerResident":303.272935,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-2.319372,"shockChange":2.205995,"controlsMeanChange":4.525367,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/16009"},{"geoid":"02130","name":"Ketchikan Gateway Borough, AK","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":388.17364,"baselinePerResident":92.310447,"ratio":4.205089,"increasePerResident":295.863193,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-3.206825,"shockChange":2.314727,"controlsMeanChange":5.521551,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/02130"},{"geoid":"38053","name":"McKenzie County, ND","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":299.020668,"baselinePerResident":3.198886,"ratio":93.47649,"increasePerResident":295.821782,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-6.360988,"shockChange":-0.780608,"controlsMeanChange":5.58038,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/38053"},{"geoid":"40035","name":"Craig County, OK","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":328.681297,"baselinePerResident":37.364799,"ratio":8.796549,"increasePerResident":291.316498,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":5.879443,"shockChange":12.097961,"controlsMeanChange":6.218518,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/40035"},{"geoid":"21065","name":"Estill County, KY","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":358.97558,"baselinePerResident":90.657238,"ratio":3.959701,"increasePerResident":268.318342,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-1.795281,"shockChange":0.738546,"controlsMeanChange":2.533826,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/21065"},{"geoid":"02170","name":"Matanuska-Susitna Borough, AK","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":280.457047,"baselinePerResident":37.735525,"ratio":7.432176,"increasePerResident":242.721522,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":4.969302,"shockChange":5.767607,"controlsMeanChange":0.798304,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/02170"},{"geoid":"12039","name":"Gadsden County, FL","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":318.834824,"baselinePerResident":76.685172,"ratio":4.157712,"increasePerResident":242.149652,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":4.478877,"shockChange":10.379359,"controlsMeanChange":5.900482,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/12039"},{"geoid":"54019","name":"Fayette County, WV","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":314.245187,"baselinePerResident":87.368765,"ratio":3.596768,"increasePerResident":226.876421,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":8.584205,"shockChange":19.37266,"controlsMeanChange":10.788455,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/54019"},{"geoid":"55053","name":"Jackson County, WI","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":267.853421,"baselinePerResident":53.191495,"ratio":5.035644,"increasePerResident":214.661926,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":0.413307,"shockChange":12.602411,"controlsMeanChange":12.189104,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/55053"},{"geoid":"40039","name":"Custer County, OK","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":236.017717,"baselinePerResident":25.096862,"ratio":9.404272,"increasePerResident":210.920854,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":11.816498,"shockChange":16.641256,"controlsMeanChange":4.824758,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/40039"},{"geoid":"54031","name":"Hardy County, WV","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":220.52972,"baselinePerResident":16.905704,"ratio":13.044693,"increasePerResident":203.624016,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":1.133771,"shockChange":15.084974,"controlsMeanChange":13.951203,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/54031"},{"geoid":"22009","name":"Avoyelles Parish, LA","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":351.624757,"baselinePerResident":150.316432,"ratio":2.33923,"increasePerResident":201.308325,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-14.071606,"shockChange":-15.370912,"controlsMeanChange":-1.299306,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/22009"},{"geoid":"31037","name":"Colfax County, NE","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":237.951024,"baselinePerResident":40.795783,"ratio":5.832736,"increasePerResident":197.155241,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":7.293905,"shockChange":15.759571,"controlsMeanChange":8.465666,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/31037"},{"geoid":"55103","name":"Richland County, WI","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":292.356296,"baselinePerResident":96.87054,"ratio":3.01801,"increasePerResident":195.485757,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":8.033798,"shockChange":22.336253,"controlsMeanChange":14.302455,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/55103"},{"geoid":"01075","name":"Lamar County, AL","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":363.82861,"baselinePerResident":169.366258,"ratio":2.148176,"increasePerResident":194.462352,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-10.28314,"shockChange":-6.498968,"controlsMeanChange":3.784173,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/01075"},{"geoid":"45049","name":"Hampton County, SC","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":227.052377,"baselinePerResident":34.132965,"ratio":6.651997,"increasePerResident":192.919412,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-2.191009,"shockChange":6.754834,"controlsMeanChange":8.945843,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/45049"},{"geoid":"54007","name":"Braxton County, WV","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":223.675295,"baselinePerResident":31.659487,"ratio":7.065032,"increasePerResident":192.015807,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-7.54957,"shockChange":3.259404,"controlsMeanChange":10.808974,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/54007"},{"geoid":"19045","name":"Clinton County, IA","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":280.074724,"baselinePerResident":90.791672,"ratio":3.084806,"increasePerResident":189.283052,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-3.780638,"shockChange":5.167467,"controlsMeanChange":8.948104,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/19045"},{"geoid":"31159","name":"Seward County, NE","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":242.65299,"baselinePerResident":54.154053,"ratio":4.480791,"increasePerResident":188.498938,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":1.95239,"shockChange":10.614268,"controlsMeanChange":8.661878,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/31159"},{"geoid":"48331","name":"Milam County, TX","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":285.193025,"baselinePerResident":100.969158,"ratio":2.824556,"increasePerResident":184.223867,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-5.338454,"shockChange":-4.861543,"controlsMeanChange":0.47691,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/48331"},{"geoid":"13081","name":"Crisp County, GA","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":363.604406,"baselinePerResident":180.711109,"ratio":2.012076,"increasePerResident":182.893297,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":7.519133,"shockChange":16.760411,"controlsMeanChange":9.241277,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/13081"},{"geoid":"23021","name":"Piscataquis County, ME","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":297.811034,"baselinePerResident":115.495725,"ratio":2.578546,"increasePerResident":182.315308,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":3.631711,"shockChange":10.962293,"controlsMeanChange":7.330582,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/23021"},{"geoid":"55007","name":"Bayfield County, WI","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":299.485185,"baselinePerResident":120.066397,"ratio":2.49433,"increasePerResident":179.418787,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-7.906773,"shockChange":7.933471,"controlsMeanChange":15.840243,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/55007"},{"geoid":"50003","name":"Bennington County, VT","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":321.739786,"baselinePerResident":142.609907,"ratio":2.256083,"increasePerResident":179.129879,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-4.284298,"shockChange":-4.067614,"controlsMeanChange":0.216684,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/50003"},{"geoid":"13095","name":"Dougherty County, GA","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":301.38787,"baselinePerResident":124.57161,"ratio":2.419395,"increasePerResident":176.81626,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-0.94898,"shockChange":7.664133,"controlsMeanChange":8.613113,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/13095"},{"geoid":"35006","name":"Cibola County, NM","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":243.663978,"baselinePerResident":67.688772,"ratio":3.59977,"increasePerResident":175.975206,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":2.965566,"shockChange":7.734244,"controlsMeanChange":4.768678,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/35006"},{"geoid":"21011","name":"Bath County, KY","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":229.657887,"baselinePerResident":57.307146,"ratio":4.007491,"increasePerResident":172.35074,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":2.402041,"shockChange":10.719101,"controlsMeanChange":8.317061,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/21011"},{"geoid":"33019","name":"Sullivan County, NH","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":307.530572,"baselinePerResident":137.770963,"ratio":2.232187,"increasePerResident":169.759609,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":3.408093,"shockChange":8.358372,"controlsMeanChange":4.950278,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/33019"},{"geoid":"12059","name":"Holmes County, FL","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":219.672083,"baselinePerResident":51.027889,"ratio":4.304942,"increasePerResident":168.644193,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":0.566365,"shockChange":6.016812,"controlsMeanChange":5.450447,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/12059"},{"geoid":"35039","name":"Rio Arriba County, NM","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":301.258456,"baselinePerResident":133.678974,"ratio":2.253596,"increasePerResident":167.579482,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-8.845115,"shockChange":3.635469,"controlsMeanChange":12.480584,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/35039"},{"geoid":"08105","name":"Rio Grande County, CO","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":311.182052,"baselinePerResident":146.634249,"ratio":2.122165,"increasePerResident":164.547802,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":5.478667,"shockChange":8.770454,"controlsMeanChange":3.291787,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/08105"},{"geoid":"55113","name":"Sawyer County, WI","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":220.439662,"baselinePerResident":57.815994,"ratio":3.81278,"increasePerResident":162.623668,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-9.838315,"shockChange":3.370478,"controlsMeanChange":13.208793,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/55113"},{"geoid":"21133","name":"Letcher County, KY","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":228.993354,"baselinePerResident":69.86317,"ratio":3.277741,"increasePerResident":159.130184,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-15.724778,"shockChange":-13.291214,"controlsMeanChange":2.433564,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/21133"},{"geoid":"47073","name":"Hawkins County, TN","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":193.733047,"baselinePerResident":36.281298,"ratio":5.33975,"increasePerResident":157.451749,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":3.10996,"shockChange":14.729213,"controlsMeanChange":11.619253,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/47073"},{"geoid":"23025","name":"Somerset County, ME","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":199.155421,"baselinePerResident":42.77446,"ratio":4.655942,"increasePerResident":156.38096,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":6.681809,"shockChange":13.527145,"controlsMeanChange":6.845336,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/23025"},{"geoid":"23023","name":"Sagadahoc County, ME","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":236.887348,"baselinePerResident":80.967383,"ratio":2.925713,"increasePerResident":155.919966,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":6.378809,"shockChange":13.510534,"controlsMeanChange":7.131725,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/23023"},{"geoid":"41031","name":"Jefferson County, OR","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":241.323696,"baselinePerResident":92.04502,"ratio":2.621801,"increasePerResident":149.278676,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-2.213301,"shockChange":5.174405,"controlsMeanChange":7.387705,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/41031"},{"geoid":"29133","name":"Mississippi County, MO","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":262.62077,"baselinePerResident":122.449711,"ratio":2.144723,"increasePerResident":140.17106,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-11.089616,"shockChange":-1.096692,"controlsMeanChange":9.992925,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/29133"},{"geoid":"29147","name":"Nodaway County, MO","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":223.245933,"baselinePerResident":84.395631,"ratio":2.645231,"increasePerResident":138.850302,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-1.930776,"shockChange":6.314514,"controlsMeanChange":8.24529,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/29147"},{"geoid":"23017","name":"Oxford County, ME","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":252.252457,"baselinePerResident":115.599258,"ratio":2.182129,"increasePerResident":136.653199,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":4.084429,"shockChange":4.045976,"controlsMeanChange":-0.038453,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/23017"},{"geoid":"06033","name":"Lake County, CA","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":258.542163,"baselinePerResident":122.853795,"ratio":2.10447,"increasePerResident":135.688368,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-9.916803,"shockChange":-3.880462,"controlsMeanChange":6.03634,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/06033"},{"geoid":"20085","name":"Jackson County, KS","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":247.186052,"baselinePerResident":112.545304,"ratio":2.196325,"increasePerResident":134.640748,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":7.605673,"shockChange":21.240041,"controlsMeanChange":13.634368,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/20085"},{"geoid":"02122","name":"Kenai Peninsula Borough, AK","fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":193.941375,"baselinePerResident":64.559438,"ratio":3.004075,"increasePerResident":129.381937,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-2.557585,"shockChange":-0.64431,"controlsMeanChange":1.913275,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/02122"},{"geoid":"26031","name":"Cheboygan County, MI","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":172.970624,"baselinePerResident":44.056352,"ratio":3.926122,"increasePerResident":128.914272,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":1.447439,"shockChange":8.585806,"controlsMeanChange":7.138367,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/26031"},{"geoid":"21069","name":"Fleming County, KY","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":185.630943,"baselinePerResident":57.364152,"ratio":3.23601,"increasePerResident":128.266791,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":10.804047,"shockChange":14.193333,"controlsMeanChange":3.389286,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/21069"},{"geoid":"36079","name":"Putnam County, NY","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":140.55197,"baselinePerResident":13.692169,"ratio":10.265136,"increasePerResident":126.859801,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":3.424395,"shockChange":11.339404,"controlsMeanChange":7.915009,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/36079"},{"geoid":"47015","name":"Cannon County, TN","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":167.636055,"baselinePerResident":40.863562,"ratio":4.102336,"increasePerResident":126.772494,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":0.59853,"shockChange":9.327958,"controlsMeanChange":8.729428,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/47015"},{"geoid":"08003","name":"Alamosa County, CO","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":240.522252,"baselinePerResident":117.352006,"ratio":2.049579,"increasePerResident":123.170247,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":3.38749,"shockChange":5.882108,"controlsMeanChange":2.494618,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/08003"},{"geoid":"54009","name":"Brooke County, WV","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":155.080007,"baselinePerResident":34.051203,"ratio":4.554318,"increasePerResident":121.028805,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":1.848496,"shockChange":8.488418,"controlsMeanChange":6.639922,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/54009"},{"geoid":"01089","name":"Madison County, AL","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":214.756677,"baselinePerResident":94.576239,"ratio":2.270725,"increasePerResident":120.180438,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-3.221482,"shockChange":-0.393317,"controlsMeanChange":2.828165,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/01089"},{"geoid":"29067","name":"Douglas County, MO","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":141.596778,"baselinePerResident":22.417312,"ratio":6.316403,"increasePerResident":119.179466,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":1.336111,"shockChange":8.977793,"controlsMeanChange":7.641682,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/29067"},{"geoid":"40117","name":"Pawnee County, OK","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":190.566864,"baselinePerResident":71.671229,"ratio":2.658903,"increasePerResident":118.895635,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":1.595815,"shockChange":8.528325,"controlsMeanChange":6.93251,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/40117"},{"geoid":"55005","name":"Barron County, WI","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":200.531931,"baselinePerResident":89.507352,"ratio":2.240396,"increasePerResident":111.024579,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-2.867037,"shockChange":11.598533,"controlsMeanChange":14.46557,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/55005"},{"geoid":"47159","name":"Smith County, TN","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":149.261467,"baselinePerResident":41.476288,"ratio":3.598718,"increasePerResident":107.785179,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-6.731254,"shockChange":3.712568,"controlsMeanChange":10.443822,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/47159"},{"geoid":"53041","name":"Lewis County, WA","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":111.69166,"baselinePerResident":6.398425,"ratio":17.456118,"increasePerResident":105.293235,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":3.777491,"shockChange":5.557995,"controlsMeanChange":1.780504,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/53041"},{"geoid":"18105","name":"Monroe County, IN","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":182.793035,"baselinePerResident":78.268289,"ratio":2.335467,"increasePerResident":104.524747,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-0.986638,"shockChange":6.602193,"controlsMeanChange":7.588831,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/18105"},{"geoid":"54061","name":"Monongalia County, WV","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":133.758849,"baselinePerResident":29.558068,"ratio":4.525291,"increasePerResident":104.200781,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-0.137965,"shockChange":5.055781,"controlsMeanChange":5.193746,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/54061"},{"geoid":"36043","name":"Herkimer County, NY","fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":196.481548,"baselinePerResident":93.137141,"ratio":2.109594,"increasePerResident":103.344407,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-0.674707,"shockChange":10.473831,"controlsMeanChange":11.148538,"outsideControlRange":false},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/36043"},{"geoid":"29053","name":"Cooper County, MO","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":129.926465,"baselinePerResident":27.167498,"ratio":4.782423,"increasePerResident":102.758967,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-8.837916,"shockChange":1.775251,"controlsMeanChange":10.613167,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/29053"},{"geoid":"17075","name":"Iroquois County, IL","fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":116.926636,"baselinePerResident":15.09269,"ratio":7.747236,"increasePerResident":101.833946,"controls":5,"headline":{"difference":-7.920969,"shockChange":1.717993,"controlsMeanChange":9.638963,"outsideControlRange":true},"href":"/api/v1/outcomes/places/17075"}],"excluded":{"singleRecipientSpike":45,"followsEarlierShock":12,"unmatched":1},"caveats":[{"id":"obligations","text":"Money is counted when the government commits it (obligations), not when it is paid out; a multi-year contract can be obligated at once."},{"id":"place-of-performance","text":"Money is placed where the work is performed or the program operates, which is not always where the jobs, workers or beneficiaries are."},{"id":"few-years","text":"Only a few fiscal years of money are loaded (see the coverage), so each comparison follows a place for one or two years after the money at most."},{"id":"small-samples","text":"Some comparisons rest on few places: read the number of places and the uncertainty range with every result."},{"id":"association","text":"These are comparisons, not proof of cause and effect: other events in the same places and years can explain a difference."},{"id":"many-comparisons","text":"Many pairings and years are compared at once: by chance alone, about one clear difference in twenty can appear where there is none."},{"id":"matched-counties","text":"Each place is compared with similar counties in the same Census division that saw no comparable jump in money; similar is not identical."},{"id":"pairing","text":"Home values follow interest rates and regional markets; housing aid is small relative to the market."}],"sources":[{"id":"bea-regional","name":"Regional Economic Accounts","publisher":"U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis","attribution":"U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, Personal Income by County (CAINC1) and Regional Price Parities; counties mapped to metro areas with OMB Bulletin 23-01 delineations","homepage":"https://www.bea.gov/data/by-place-county-metro-local","vintage":"2024","loadedAt":"2026-09-30T21:50:03.389Z"},{"id":"bls-laus","name":"Local Area Unemployment Statistics","publisher":"U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics","attribution":"U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Local Area Unemployment Statistics","homepage":"https://www.bls.gov/lau/","vintage":"2025","loadedAt":"2026-09-30T21:51:58.235Z"},{"id":"bls-qcew","name":"Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages","publisher":"U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics","attribution":"U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages","homepage":"https://www.bls.gov/cew/","vintage":"2026 Q1","loadedAt":"2026-09-30T21:54:22.947Z"},{"id":"census-bfs","name":"Business Formation Statistics","publisher":"U.S. Census Bureau","attribution":"U.S. Census Bureau, Business Formation Statistics (county business applications)","homepage":"https://www.census.gov/econ/bfs/","vintage":"2026-10-01","loadedAt":"2026-10-01T15:51:40.026Z"},{"id":"census-bps","name":"Building Permits Survey","publisher":"U.S. Census Bureau","attribution":"U.S. Census Bureau, Building Permits Survey (county files)","homepage":"https://www.census.gov/construction/bps/","vintage":"2026-08","loadedAt":"2026-09-30T22:14:14.060Z"},{"id":"census-geo","name":"Cartographic Boundary Files, Gazetteer and metro delineations","publisher":"U.S. Census Bureau","attribution":"U.S. Census Bureau, Cartographic Boundary Files and Gazetteer Files; OMB metropolitan and micropolitan statistical area delineations; American Community Survey 5-year population (city and county shares)","homepage":"https://www.census.gov/geographies/mapping-files/time-series/geo/cartographic-boundary.html","vintage":"2025","loadedAt":"2026-10-01T07:50:40.343Z"},{"id":"census-pep","name":"Population Estimates Program","publisher":"U.S. Census Bureau","attribution":"U.S. Census Bureau, Population Estimates Program","homepage":"https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/popest.html","vintage":"2025","loadedAt":"2026-09-30T22:05:38.461Z"},{"id":"census-sahie","name":"Small Area Health Insurance Estimates","publisher":"U.S. Census Bureau","attribution":"U.S. Census Bureau, Small Area Health Insurance Estimates (SAHIE)","homepage":"https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/sahie.html","vintage":"2024","loadedAt":"2026-09-29T09:23:29.353Z"},{"id":"census-saipe","name":"Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates","publisher":"U.S. Census Bureau","attribution":"U.S. Census Bureau, Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates (SAIPE)","homepage":"https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/saipe.html","vintage":"2024","loadedAt":"2026-09-29T09:23:19.832Z"},{"id":"usaspending-assistance","name":"Federal financial assistance transactions (Financial Assistance Broker Submission)","publisher":"U.S. Department of the Treasury, USAspending.gov","attribution":"USAspending.gov, prime award financial assistance transactions (FABS)","homepage":"https://www.usaspending.gov/download_center/award_data_archive","vintage":"2026-10-08","loadedAt":"2026-10-08T06:32:13.987Z"},{"id":"usaspending-contracts","name":"Federal contract transactions (Federal Procurement Data System)","publisher":"U.S. Department of the Treasury, USAspending.gov","attribution":"USAspending.gov, prime award contract transactions (FPDS)","homepage":"https://www.usaspending.gov/download_center/award_data_archive","vintage":"2026-10-09","loadedAt":"2026-10-09T06:23:41.399Z"},{"id":"zillow","name":"Zillow Home Value Index, Observed Rent Index and affordability","publisher":"Zillow Research","attribution":"Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI), Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI) and Zillow affordability data, Zillow Research, zillow.com/research/data","homepage":"https://www.zillow.com/research/data/","vintage":"2026-08","loadedAt":"2026-09-30T22:06:10.720Z"}]}