{"format":1,"version":"5fac9b5fb484a85b","methodVersion":"outcomes@1","place":{"geoid":"26019","name":"Benzie County, MI","level":"county"},"money":[{"domain":"contracts","series":[{"fiscalYear":2017,"amount":490015.97,"perResident":27.802325,"population":17625,"populationYear":2017,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2018,"amount":1799201.33,"perResident":101.374878,"population":17748,"populationYear":2018,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2019,"amount":12644030.44,"perResident":711.658155,"population":17767,"populationYear":2019,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2020,"amount":3712378.86,"perResident":206.220357,"population":18002,"populationYear":2020,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2021,"amount":867990.93,"perResident":47.574181,"population":18245,"populationYear":2021,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2022,"amount":221997.51,"perResident":12.104553,"population":18340,"populationYear":2022,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2023,"amount":18143648.06,"perResident":983.288969,"population":18452,"populationYear":2023,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2024,"amount":-1938742.28,"perResident":-104.842217,"population":18492,"populationYear":2024,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2025,"amount":6945447.74,"perResident":374.054704,"population":18568,"populationYear":2025,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2026,"amount":-83198.69,"perResident":-4.480757,"population":18568,"populationYear":2025,"complete":false,"covered":true}],"national":[{"fiscalYear":2017,"perResident":1435.502146},{"fiscalYear":2018,"perResident":1552.376671},{"fiscalYear":2019,"perResident":1654.178773},{"fiscalYear":2020,"perResident":1880.176348},{"fiscalYear":2021,"perResident":1809.737951},{"fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":1916.864722},{"fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":2079.263916},{"fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":2047.147384},{"fiscalYear":2025,"perResident":2164.957435},{"fiscalYear":2026,"perResident":1912.198848},{"fiscalYear":2027,"perResident":null}]},{"domain":"construction-contracts","series":[{"fiscalYear":2017,"amount":151507.03,"perResident":8.596144,"population":17625,"populationYear":2017,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2018,"amount":758500,"perResident":42.73721,"population":17748,"populationYear":2018,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2019,"amount":1049285.54,"perResident":59.058116,"population":17767,"populationYear":2019,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2020,"amount":4158,"perResident":0.230974,"population":18002,"populationYear":2020,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2021,"amount":-79294,"perResident":-4.346067,"population":18245,"populationYear":2021,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2025,"amount":1370980.23,"perResident":73.835644,"population":18568,"populationYear":2025,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2026,"amount":9694,"perResident":0.522081,"population":18568,"populationYear":2025,"complete":false,"covered":true}],"national":[{"fiscalYear":2017,"perResident":93.282985},{"fiscalYear":2018,"perResident":104.978583},{"fiscalYear":2019,"perResident":127.555736},{"fiscalYear":2020,"perResident":145.285162},{"fiscalYear":2021,"perResident":117.109284},{"fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":137.651069},{"fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":158.667891},{"fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":157.030035},{"fiscalYear":2025,"perResident":148.515558},{"fiscalYear":2026,"perResident":211.124648},{"fiscalYear":2027,"perResident":null}]},{"domain":"contracts-and-grants","series":[{"fiscalYear":2021,"amount":2557961.85,"perResident":140.200704,"population":18245,"populationYear":2021,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2022,"amount":10268164.28,"perResident":559.878096,"population":18340,"populationYear":2022,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2023,"amount":37823766.2,"perResident":2049.846423,"population":18452,"populationYear":2023,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2024,"amount":-4477011.37,"perResident":-242.105309,"population":18492,"populationYear":2024,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2025,"amount":10936289.83,"perResident":588.985881,"population":18568,"populationYear":2025,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2026,"amount":10816012.34,"perResident":582.508204,"population":18568,"populationYear":2025,"complete":false,"covered":true}],"national":[{"fiscalYear":2021,"perResident":5748.050527},{"fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":5221.02781},{"fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":5364.418421},{"fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":5500.590497},{"fiscalYear":2025,"perResident":5731.548522},{"fiscalYear":2026,"perResident":5446.993718}]},{"domain":"transportation-grants","series":[{"fiscalYear":2021,"amount":854329.92,"perResident":46.825427,"population":18245,"populationYear":2021,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2022,"amount":5932023.77,"perResident":323.447316,"population":18340,"populationYear":2022,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2023,"amount":20107646.49,"perResident":1089.727211,"population":18452,"populationYear":2023,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2024,"amount":-2654537.09,"perResident":-143.550567,"population":18492,"populationYear":2024,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2025,"amount":1914466.09,"perResident":103.105671,"population":18568,"populationYear":2025,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2026,"amount":10824744.03,"perResident":582.978459,"population":18568,"populationYear":2025,"complete":false,"covered":true}],"national":[{"fiscalYear":2021,"perResident":297.670127},{"fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":356.760342},{"fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":300.580186},{"fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":319.027251},{"fiscalYear":2025,"perResident":359.528623},{"fiscalYear":2026,"perResident":348.520158}]},{"domain":"housing-assistance","series":[{"fiscalYear":2021,"amount":54704,"perResident":2.998301,"population":18245,"populationYear":2021,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2022,"amount":72940.51,"perResident":3.977127,"population":18340,"populationYear":2022,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2023,"amount":84958.32,"perResident":4.604288,"population":18452,"populationYear":2023,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2024,"amount":218788.77,"perResident":11.831536,"population":18492,"populationYear":2024,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2025,"amount":316163,"perResident":17.027305,"population":18568,"populationYear":2025,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2026,"amount":300444,"perResident":16.180741,"population":18568,"populationYear":2025,"complete":false,"covered":true}],"national":[{"fiscalYear":2021,"perResident":239.026205},{"fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":184.975081},{"fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":228.509987},{"fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":228.797322},{"fiscalYear":2025,"perResident":248.669387},{"fiscalYear":2026,"perResident":201.138302}]},{"domain":"health-grants","series":[{"fiscalYear":2021,"amount":99058,"perResident":5.429323,"population":18245,"populationYear":2021,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2022,"amount":0,"perResident":0,"population":18340,"populationYear":2022,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2023,"amount":0,"perResident":0,"population":18452,"populationYear":2023,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2024,"amount":0,"perResident":0,"population":18492,"populationYear":2024,"complete":true,"covered":true}],"national":[{"fiscalYear":2021,"perResident":2303.735547},{"fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":2197.092058},{"fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":2274.134861},{"fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":2267.036265},{"fiscalYear":2025,"perResident":2397.384456},{"fiscalYear":2026,"perResident":2596.935122}]},{"domain":"sba-lending","series":[{"fiscalYear":2021,"amount":13980134.44,"perResident":766.244694,"population":18245,"populationYear":2021,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2022,"amount":5593700,"perResident":305,"population":18340,"populationYear":2022,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2023,"amount":445700,"perResident":24.154563,"population":18452,"populationYear":2023,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2024,"amount":1269700,"perResident":68.662124,"population":18492,"populationYear":2024,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2025,"amount":-134400,"perResident":-7.238259,"population":18568,"populationYear":2025,"complete":true,"covered":true},{"fiscalYear":2026,"amount":808300,"perResident":43.531883,"population":18568,"populationYear":2025,"complete":false,"covered":true}],"national":[{"fiscalYear":2021,"perResident":1185.796346},{"fiscalYear":2022,"perResident":465.071349},{"fiscalYear":2023,"perResident":76.517192},{"fiscalYear":2024,"perResident":119.8789},{"fiscalYear":2025,"perResident":147.755033},{"fiscalYear":2026,"perResident":108.074734}]}],"outcomes":[{"key":"job_growth_rate","comparison":"points","chart":"value","baseYear":2016,"series":[{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":0.9,"change":-1.9},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":-0.5,"change":-3.3},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":2.8,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":2.5,"change":-0.3},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":1.3,"change":-1.5},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":2.4,"change":-0.4},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":-10,"change":-12.8},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":9.7,"change":6.9},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":8.4,"change":5.6},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":1.2,"change":-1.6},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":2.4,"change":-0.4},{"year":2025,"period":"2025","value":3,"change":0.2}],"national":[{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":2,"change":0.3},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":2.1,"change":0.4},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":1.7,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":1.4,"change":-0.3},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":1.6,"change":-0.1},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":1.4,"change":-0.3},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":-6.1,"change":-7.8},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":3.4,"change":1.7},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":4.3,"change":2.6},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":2.1,"change":0.4},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":1.2,"change":-0.5},{"year":2025,"period":"2025","value":0.5,"change":-1.2}]},{"key":"average_weekly_wage","comparison":"percent","chart":"change","baseYear":2016,"series":[{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":571,"change":-6.546645},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":600,"change":-1.800327},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":611,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":624,"change":2.12766},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":652,"change":6.710311},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":667,"change":9.165303},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":731,"change":19.639935},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":766,"change":25.368249},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":795,"change":30.114566},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":833,"change":36.333879},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":877,"change":43.535188},{"year":2025,"period":"2025","value":891,"change":45.826514}],"national":[{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":988,"change":-4.170708},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":1018,"change":-1.260912},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":1031,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":1065,"change":3.297769},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":1101,"change":6.789525},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":1139,"change":10.475267},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":1231,"change":19.398642},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":1300,"change":26.091174},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":1346,"change":30.552861},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":1392,"change":35.014549},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":1454,"change":41.028128},{"year":2025,"period":"2025","value":1514,"change":46.847721}]},{"key":"unemployment_rate","comparison":"points","chart":"value","baseYear":2016,"series":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":10.4,"change":3.6},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":10.3,"change":3.5},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":8.6,"change":1.8},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":7,"change":0.2},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":6.8,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":6.6,"change":-0.2},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":5.7,"change":-1.1},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":5.3,"change":-1.5},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":10.1,"change":3.3},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":5.9,"change":-0.9},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":5.4,"change":-1.4},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":5.1,"change":-1.7},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":5.3,"change":-1.5},{"year":2025,"period":"2025","value":5.7,"change":-1.1}],"national":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":8.069792147657774,"change":3.201238},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":7.3748609463936745,"change":2.506307},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":6.1674445607651975,"change":1.29889},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":5.278969099622827,"change":0.410415},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":4.868554164935979,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":4.355232287949445,"change":-0.513322},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":3.895602492636489,"change":-0.972952},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":3.669080964698064,"change":-1.199473},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":8.069743547451617,"change":3.201189},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":5.354733138285382,"change":0.486179},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":3.65042617761736,"change":-1.218128},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":3.6400797830110756,"change":-1.228474},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":4.023721084656814,"change":-0.844833},{"year":2025,"period":"2025","value":4.281777047352014,"change":-0.586777}]},{"key":"per_capita_income","comparison":"percent","chart":"change","baseYear":2016,"series":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":34074,"change":-14.719059},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":34851,"change":-12.774371},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":36876,"change":-7.706169},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":39267,"change":-1.721937},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":39955,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":41876,"change":4.807909},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":43383,"change":8.579652},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":45656,"change":14.268552},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":52268,"change":30.817169},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":54925,"change":37.467151},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":56921,"change":42.462771},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":60919,"change":52.469028},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":63595,"change":59.166562}],"national":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":44238,"change":-9.670437},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":44402,"change":-9.335566},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":46289,"change":-5.482501},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":48062,"change":-1.862213},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":48974,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":51006,"change":4.14914},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":53311,"change":8.855719},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":55567,"change":13.462245},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":59151,"change":20.780414},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":64692,"change":32.094581},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":66298,"change":35.373872},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":70002,"change":42.937069},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":73204,"change":49.475232}]},{"key":"housing_permits_rate","comparison":"points","chart":"value","baseYear":2016,"series":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":3.117962930885155,"change":-1.219194},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":3.056516724336794,"change":-1.28064},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":2.347417840375587,"change":-1.989739},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":3.3360174853330267,"change":-1.001139},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":4.33715687952976,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":4.368794326241135,"change":0.031637},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":4.056795131845842,"change":-0.280362},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":3.99617267968706,"change":-0.340984},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":4.888345739362293,"change":0.551189},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":5.864620443957248,"change":1.527464},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":7.906215921483097,"change":3.569059},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":7.099501409061348,"change":2.762345},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":5.948518278174346,"change":1.611361},{"year":2025,"period":"2025","value":7.324429125376993,"change":2.987272}],"national":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":2.643252771520899,"change":-1.091651},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":3.1349179464362815,"change":-0.599986},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":3.2864570639275157,"change":-0.448447},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":3.687054028734654,"change":-0.04785},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":3.7349040308398362,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":3.9430628972753277,"change":0.208159},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":4.065702858679625,"change":0.330799},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":4.221509452108989,"change":0.486605},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":4.436785729373734,"change":0.701882},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":5.230295488620743,"change":1.495391},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":5.031097589630812,"change":1.296194},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":4.487243742968405,"change":0.75234},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":4.34701027765287,"change":0.612106},{"year":2025,"period":"2025","value":4.188646660843725,"change":0.453743}]},{"key":"median_household_income","comparison":"percent","chart":"change","baseYear":2016,"series":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":42675,"change":-15.197822},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":43145,"change":-14.263855},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":48846,"change":-2.93504},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":48127,"change":-4.36381},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":50323,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":54065,"change":7.435964},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":51905,"change":3.143692},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":56934,"change":13.137134},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":64526,"change":28.223675},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":67924,"change":34.976055},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":65846,"change":30.84673},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":65594,"change":30.345965},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":76215,"change":51.451623}],"national":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":51371,"change":-10.840551},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":52250,"change":-9.314959},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":53657,"change":-6.872972},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":55775,"change":-3.196973},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":57617,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":60336,"change":4.719093},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":61937,"change":7.497787},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":65712,"change":14.049673},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":67340,"change":16.875228},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":69717,"change":21.000746},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":74755,"change":29.744693},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":77719,"change":34.889008},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":81604,"change":41.63181}]},{"key":"poverty_rate","comparison":"points","chart":"value","baseYear":2016,"series":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":13.8,"change":3},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":13.1,"change":2.3},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":11.8,"change":1},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":10.5,"change":-0.3},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":10.8,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":9.4,"change":-1.4},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":10.3,"change":-0.5},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":9.6,"change":-1.2},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":9.5,"change":-1.3},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":9.3,"change":-1.5},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":9.9,"change":-0.9},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":9.7,"change":-1.1},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":9.2,"change":-1.6}],"national":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":15.9,"change":1.9},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":15.8,"change":1.8},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":15.5,"change":1.5},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":14.7,"change":0.7},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":14,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":13.4,"change":-0.6},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":13.1,"change":-0.9},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":12.3,"change":-1.7},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":11.9,"change":-2.1},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":12.8,"change":-1.2},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":12.6,"change":-1.4},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":12.5,"change":-1.5},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":12.1,"change":-1.9}]},{"key":"typical_home_value","comparison":"percent","chart":"change","baseYear":2016,"series":[{"year":2012,"period":"Dec 2012","value":169471.9490782751,"change":-18.299886},{"year":2013,"period":"Dec 2013","value":190333.4243046695,"change":-8.242853},{"year":2014,"period":"Dec 2014","value":201957.16521897982,"change":-2.639206},{"year":2015,"period":"Dec 2015","value":205820.0395562733,"change":-0.776967},{"year":2016,"period":"Dec 2016","value":207431.71581877302,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"Dec 2017","value":209451.11995816082,"change":0.973527},{"year":2018,"period":"Dec 2018","value":220122.90540950475,"change":6.118249},{"year":2019,"period":"Dec 2019","value":229864.2115063098,"change":10.8144},{"year":2020,"period":"Dec 2020","value":265120.3999938188,"change":27.810928},{"year":2021,"period":"Dec 2021","value":321152.5105943664,"change":54.823244},{"year":2022,"period":"Dec 2022","value":350948.8115525027,"change":69.187634},{"year":2023,"period":"Dec 2023","value":375390.8054234441,"change":80.970785},{"year":2024,"period":"Dec 2024","value":393639.36305064365,"change":89.768166},{"year":2025,"period":"Dec 2025","value":394397.5195516159,"change":90.133663}],"national":[{"year":2012,"period":"Dec 2012","value":165624.53659341528,"change":-21.537402},{"year":2013,"period":"Dec 2013","value":179024.38176016198,"change":-15.189389},{"year":2014,"period":"Dec 2014","value":188194.1151969421,"change":-10.84534},{"year":2015,"period":"Dec 2015","value":200062.4646672142,"change":-5.222855},{"year":2016,"period":"Dec 2016","value":211087.2456680348,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"Dec 2017","value":224629.1564743884,"change":6.415315},{"year":2018,"period":"Dec 2018","value":237733.41972938902,"change":12.623299},{"year":2019,"period":"Dec 2019","value":249253.53102282956,"change":18.080811},{"year":2020,"period":"Dec 2020","value":272914.76414081856,"change":29.29003},{"year":2021,"period":"Dec 2021","value":316245.3552737066,"change":49.817368},{"year":2022,"period":"Dec 2022","value":347570.0379882995,"change":64.657053},{"year":2023,"period":"Dec 2023","value":356745.35226452653,"change":69.003746},{"year":2024,"period":"Dec 2024","value":366111.6654657945,"change":73.440922},{"year":2025,"period":"Dec 2025","value":366588.38707554754,"change":73.666763}]},{"key":"market_rent","comparison":"percent","chart":"change","baseYear":2016,"series":[],"national":[{"year":2015,"period":"Dec 2015","value":1192.3408952292077,"change":-3.269133},{"year":2016,"period":"Dec 2016","value":1232.6374542108365,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"Dec 2017","value":1286.6382057681576,"change":4.380911},{"year":2018,"period":"Dec 2018","value":1341.3823608420305,"change":8.822132},{"year":2019,"period":"Dec 2019","value":1394.0869800051385,"change":13.097892},{"year":2020,"period":"Dec 2020","value":1419.6641833808835,"change":15.17289},{"year":2021,"period":"Dec 2021","value":1636.61329175691,"change":32.773289},{"year":2022,"period":"Dec 2022","value":1751.3627489954263,"change":42.082552},{"year":2023,"period":"Dec 2023","value":1802.7334097983962,"change":46.250092},{"year":2024,"period":"Dec 2024","value":1853.813785067969,"change":50.394082},{"year":2025,"period":"Dec 2025","value":1891.5780524221482,"change":53.457778}]},{"key":"uninsured_rate","comparison":"points","chart":"value","baseYear":2016,"series":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":16.6,"change":9.1},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":15.8,"change":8.3},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":12.6,"change":5.1},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":9.3,"change":1.8},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":7.5,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":7.4,"change":-0.1},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":7.9,"change":0.4},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":8.5,"change":1},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":8.3,"change":0.8},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":6.7,"change":-0.8},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":6.8,"change":-0.7},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":5.5,"change":-2},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":6.5,"change":-1}],"national":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":17.01445162685307,"change":7.005593},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":16.79407563152382,"change":6.785217},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":13.539742583766559,"change":3.530884},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":10.921693754166192,"change":0.912835},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":10.008858754395874,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":10.223446026686386,"change":0.214587},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":10.428901917339296,"change":0.420043},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":10.840542541329276,"change":0.831684},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":10.444967294065618,"change":0.436109},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":10.228549549682963,"change":0.219691},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":9.548377944175904,"change":-0.460481},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":9.457094600301255,"change":-0.551764},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":9.803529485118363,"change":-0.205329}]},{"key":"business_applications_rate","comparison":"points","chart":"value","baseYear":2016,"series":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":7.159766730180726,"change":0.083353},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":6.689734717416378,"change":-0.386679},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":4.351311118744991,"change":-2.725103},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":7.247210399171747,"change":0.170797},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":7.076413856074873,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":6.638297872340425,"change":-0.438116},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":7.2684246112238,"change":0.192011},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":6.191253447402488,"change":-0.88516},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":8.6657038106877,"change":1.58929},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":10.139764318991505,"change":3.06335},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":9.051254089422029,"change":1.97484},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":10.94732278343811,"change":3.870909},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":9.679861561756434,"change":2.603448},{"year":2025,"period":"2025","value":12.063765618267988,"change":4.987352}],"national":[{"year":2012,"period":"2012","value":8.13113613672833,"change":-0.995561},{"year":2013,"period":"2013","value":8.204174633997518,"change":-0.922522},{"year":2014,"period":"2014","value":8.45543214262821,"change":-0.671265},{"year":2015,"period":"2015","value":8.719862730504168,"change":-0.406834},{"year":2016,"period":"2016","value":9.126696946936757,"change":0},{"year":2017,"period":"2017","value":9.772678407173812,"change":0.645981},{"year":2018,"period":"2018","value":10.650257560622528,"change":1.523561},{"year":2019,"period":"2019","value":10.64931471543201,"change":1.522618},{"year":2020,"period":"2020","value":13.122362265513166,"change":3.995665},{"year":2021,"period":"2021","value":16.22138303899553,"change":7.094686},{"year":2022,"period":"2022","value":15.148814341370677,"change":6.022117},{"year":2023,"period":"2023","value":16.241273790897722,"change":7.114577},{"year":2024,"period":"2024","value":15.365075467083681,"change":6.238379},{"year":2025,"period":"2025","value":16.594936504164664,"change":7.46824}]}],"shocks":[{"domain":"contracts","geoid":"26019","fiscalYear":2019,"amount":12644030.44,"population":17767,"perResident":711.658155,"baselinePerResident":64.588601,"baselineYears":2,"ratio":11.018324,"increasePerResident":647.069554,"nextPerResident":206.220357,"persisted":false,"topRecipientShare":0.885321,"eligible":true,"exclusionReason":null,"name":"Benzie County, MI","effects":[{"outcome":"job_growth_rate","comparison":"points","baseYear":2018,"controls":[{"geoid":"26097","name":"Mackinac County, MI","distance":0.325725},{"geoid":"26011","name":"Arenac County, MI","distance":0.473634},{"geoid":"26029","name":"Charlevoix County, MI","distance":0.552819},{"geoid":"26143","name":"Roscommon County, MI","distance":0.562451},{"geoid":"26071","name":"Iron County, MI","distance":0.684998}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2016,"shockValue":2.8,"shockChange":1.5,"controlsMeanChange":1.84,"controlsMinChange":0,"controlsMaxChange":3.6,"controls":5,"difference":-0.34},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2017,"shockValue":2.5,"shockChange":1.2,"controlsMeanChange":-1.06,"controlsMinChange":-3.4,"controlsMaxChange":0,"controls":5,"difference":2.26},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2019,"shockValue":2.4,"shockChange":1.1,"controlsMeanChange":-1.96,"controlsMinChange":-4,"controlsMaxChange":0.1,"controls":5,"difference":3.06},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2020,"shockValue":-10,"shockChange":-11.3,"controlsMeanChange":-11.64,"controlsMinChange":-15,"controlsMaxChange":-7.6,"controls":5,"difference":0.34},{"relativeYear":2,"year":2021,"shockValue":9.7,"shockChange":8.4,"controlsMeanChange":3.18,"controlsMinChange":-1.1,"controlsMaxChange":8.2,"controls":5,"difference":5.22}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2020,"shockValue":-10,"shockChange":-11.3,"controlsMeanChange":-11.64,"controlsMinChange":-15,"controlsMaxChange":-7.6,"controls":5,"difference":0.34,"outsideControlRange":false}},{"outcome":"average_weekly_wage","comparison":"percent","baseYear":2018,"controls":[{"geoid":"26097","name":"Mackinac County, MI","distance":0.335395},{"geoid":"26031","name":"Cheboygan County, MI","distance":0.445731},{"geoid":"26051","name":"Gladwin County, MI","distance":0.537298},{"geoid":"26071","name":"Iron County, MI","distance":0.637404},{"geoid":"26011","name":"Arenac County, MI","distance":0.656942}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2016,"shockValue":611,"shockChange":-6.288344,"controlsMeanChange":-6.502137,"controlsMinChange":-8.017493,"controlsMaxChange":-5.070423,"controls":5,"difference":0.213794},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2017,"shockValue":624,"shockChange":-4.294479,"controlsMeanChange":-4.112348,"controlsMinChange":-5.607477,"controlsMaxChange":-2.957746,"controls":5,"difference":-0.18213},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2019,"shockValue":667,"shockChange":2.300613,"controlsMeanChange":3.081912,"controlsMinChange":1.749271,"controlsMaxChange":4.075235,"controls":5,"difference":-0.781299},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2020,"shockValue":731,"shockChange":12.116564,"controlsMeanChange":13.249402,"controlsMinChange":9.714286,"controlsMaxChange":16.77116,"controls":5,"difference":-1.132837},{"relativeYear":2,"year":2021,"shockValue":766,"shockChange":17.484663,"controlsMeanChange":18.381412,"controlsMinChange":10.56338,"controlsMaxChange":26.959248,"controls":5,"difference":-0.896749}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2020,"shockValue":731,"shockChange":12.116564,"controlsMeanChange":13.249402,"controlsMinChange":9.714286,"controlsMaxChange":16.77116,"controls":5,"difference":-1.132837,"outsideControlRange":false}},{"outcome":"unemployment_rate","comparison":"points","baseYear":2018,"controls":[{"geoid":"26079","name":"Kalkaska County, MI","distance":0.312081},{"geoid":"26071","name":"Iron County, MI","distance":0.463911},{"geoid":"26041","name":"Delta County, MI","distance":0.531733},{"geoid":"26113","name":"Missaukee County, MI","distance":0.538629},{"geoid":"26051","name":"Gladwin County, MI","distance":0.578114}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2016,"shockValue":6.8,"shockChange":1.1,"controlsMeanChange":1.14,"controlsMinChange":0.9,"controlsMaxChange":1.4,"controls":5,"difference":-0.04},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2017,"shockValue":6.6,"shockChange":0.9,"controlsMeanChange":0.8,"controlsMinChange":0.6,"controlsMaxChange":0.9,"controls":5,"difference":0.1},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2019,"shockValue":5.3,"shockChange":-0.4,"controlsMeanChange":-0.08,"controlsMinChange":-0.3,"controlsMaxChange":0.1,"controls":5,"difference":-0.32},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2020,"shockValue":10.1,"shockChange":4.4,"controlsMeanChange":4.28,"controlsMinChange":3.6,"controlsMaxChange":5.5,"controls":5,"difference":0.12},{"relativeYear":2,"year":2021,"shockValue":5.9,"shockChange":0.2,"controlsMeanChange":0.68,"controlsMinChange":-0.1,"controlsMaxChange":1.1,"controls":5,"difference":-0.48}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2020,"shockValue":10.1,"shockChange":4.4,"controlsMeanChange":4.28,"controlsMinChange":3.6,"controlsMaxChange":5.5,"controls":5,"difference":0.12,"outsideControlRange":false}},{"outcome":"per_capita_income","comparison":"percent","baseYear":2018,"controls":[{"geoid":"26109","name":"Menominee County, MI","distance":0.367471},{"geoid":"26137","name":"Otsego County, MI","distance":0.67904},{"geoid":"26063","name":"Huron County, MI","distance":0.782907},{"geoid":"26141","name":"Presque Isle County, MI","distance":0.811118},{"geoid":"26011","name":"Arenac County, MI","distance":0.820124}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2016,"shockValue":39955,"shockChange":-7.901713,"controlsMeanChange":-7.273736,"controlsMinChange":-8.756757,"controlsMaxChange":-5.831755,"controls":5,"difference":-0.627976},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2017,"shockValue":41876,"shockChange":-3.473711,"controlsMeanChange":-4.131482,"controlsMinChange":-5.531532,"controlsMaxChange":-3.212485,"controls":5,"difference":0.657771},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2019,"shockValue":45656,"shockChange":5.239379,"controlsMeanChange":2.809295,"controlsMinChange":-0.325172,"controlsMaxChange":6.994763,"controls":5,"difference":2.430085},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2020,"shockValue":52268,"shockChange":20.480372,"controlsMeanChange":15.35371,"controlsMinChange":7.658521,"controlsMaxChange":20.411965,"controls":5,"difference":5.126662},{"relativeYear":2,"year":2021,"shockValue":54925,"shockChange":26.604891,"controlsMeanChange":25.224016,"controlsMinChange":17.82135,"controlsMaxChange":30.655502,"controls":5,"difference":1.380875}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2020,"shockValue":52268,"shockChange":20.480372,"controlsMeanChange":15.35371,"controlsMinChange":7.658521,"controlsMaxChange":20.411965,"controls":5,"difference":5.126662,"outsideControlRange":true}}]},{"domain":"transportation-grants","geoid":"26019","fiscalYear":2022,"amount":5932023.77,"population":18340,"perResident":323.447316,"baselinePerResident":46.825427,"baselineYears":1,"ratio":6.907514,"increasePerResident":276.621888,"nextPerResident":1089.727211,"persisted":true,"topRecipientShare":1,"eligible":true,"exclusionReason":null,"name":"Benzie County, MI","effects":[{"outcome":"job_growth_rate","comparison":"points","baseYear":2021,"controls":[{"geoid":"39135","name":"Preble County, OH","distance":1.083215},{"geoid":"39043","name":"Erie County, OH","distance":1.298979},{"geoid":"18013","name":"Brown County, IN","distance":1.396607},{"geoid":"18147","name":"Spencer County, IN","distance":1.480782},{"geoid":"26059","name":"Hillsdale County, MI","distance":1.490566}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2019,"shockValue":2.4,"shockChange":-7.3,"controlsMeanChange":-7.68,"controlsMinChange":-9.8,"controlsMaxChange":-6.4,"controls":5,"difference":0.38},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2020,"shockValue":-10,"shockChange":-19.7,"controlsMeanChange":-15.68,"controlsMinChange":-17.8,"controlsMaxChange":-11.6,"controls":5,"difference":-4.02},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2022,"shockValue":8.4,"shockChange":-1.3,"controlsMeanChange":-3.8,"controlsMinChange":-6,"controlsMaxChange":-2.8,"controls":5,"difference":2.5},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2023,"shockValue":1.2,"shockChange":-8.5,"controlsMeanChange":-4.24,"controlsMinChange":-9.1,"controlsMaxChange":0.9,"controls":5,"difference":-4.26},{"relativeYear":2,"year":2024,"shockValue":2.4,"shockChange":-7.3,"controlsMeanChange":-5.06,"controlsMinChange":-7.1,"controlsMaxChange":-0.7,"controls":5,"difference":-2.24}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2023,"shockValue":1.2,"shockChange":-8.5,"controlsMeanChange":-4.24,"controlsMinChange":-9.1,"controlsMaxChange":0.9,"controls":5,"difference":-4.26,"outsideControlRange":false}},{"outcome":"housing_permits_rate","comparison":"points","baseYear":2021,"controls":[{"geoid":"26009","name":"Antrim County, MI","distance":0.678177},{"geoid":"26089","name":"Leelanau County, MI","distance":0.721454},{"geoid":"26143","name":"Roscommon County, MI","distance":0.843269},{"geoid":"26105","name":"Mason County, MI","distance":0.881824},{"geoid":"26165","name":"Wexford County, MI","distance":0.968441}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2019,"shockValue":3.996173,"shockChange":-1.868448,"controlsMeanChange":-0.957648,"controlsMinChange":-1.827877,"controlsMaxChange":-0.549858,"controls":5,"difference":-0.9108},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2020,"shockValue":4.888346,"shockChange":-0.976275,"controlsMeanChange":-0.976647,"controlsMinChange":-2.884636,"controlsMaxChange":-0.062393,"controls":5,"difference":0.000373},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2022,"shockValue":7.906216,"shockChange":2.041595,"controlsMeanChange":-0.357203,"controlsMinChange":-1.124354,"controlsMaxChange":0.401759,"controls":5,"difference":2.398798},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2023,"shockValue":7.099501,"shockChange":1.234881,"controlsMeanChange":0.217186,"controlsMinChange":-0.69694,"controlsMaxChange":1.057123,"controls":5,"difference":1.017695},{"relativeYear":2,"year":2024,"shockValue":5.948518,"shockChange":0.083898,"controlsMeanChange":0.726511,"controlsMinChange":-0.365281,"controlsMaxChange":2.648288,"controls":5,"difference":-0.642613}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2023,"shockValue":7.099501,"shockChange":1.234881,"controlsMeanChange":0.217186,"controlsMinChange":-0.69694,"controlsMaxChange":1.057123,"controls":5,"difference":1.017695,"outsideControlRange":true}}]},{"domain":"contracts","geoid":"26019","fiscalYear":2023,"amount":18143648.06,"population":18452,"perResident":983.288969,"baselinePerResident":184.455741,"baselineYears":6,"ratio":5.330758,"increasePerResident":798.833228,"nextPerResident":-104.842217,"persisted":false,"topRecipientShare":0.873348,"eligible":true,"exclusionReason":null,"name":"Benzie County, MI","effects":[{"outcome":"job_growth_rate","comparison":"points","baseYear":2022,"controls":[{"geoid":"26097","name":"Mackinac County, MI","distance":0.548859},{"geoid":"17185","name":"Wabash County, IL","distance":1.129711},{"geoid":"26029","name":"Charlevoix County, MI","distance":1.205593},{"geoid":"18087","name":"LaGrange County, IN","distance":1.241931},{"geoid":"18045","name":"Fountain County, IN","distance":1.27734}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2020,"shockValue":-10,"shockChange":-18.4,"controlsMeanChange":-16.48,"controlsMinChange":-20,"controlsMaxChange":-14.1,"controls":5,"difference":-1.92},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2021,"shockValue":9.7,"shockChange":1.3,"controlsMeanChange":-1.38,"controlsMinChange":-13.1,"controlsMaxChange":5.1,"controls":5,"difference":2.68},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2023,"shockValue":1.2,"shockChange":-7.2,"controlsMeanChange":-6.92,"controlsMinChange":-13.1,"controlsMaxChange":-3,"controls":5,"difference":-0.28},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":2.4,"shockChange":-6,"controlsMeanChange":-7.78,"controlsMinChange":-10.5,"controlsMaxChange":-4.2,"controls":5,"difference":1.78},{"relativeYear":2,"year":2025,"shockValue":3,"shockChange":-5.4,"controlsMeanChange":-9.22,"controlsMinChange":-11.8,"controlsMaxChange":-6.4,"controls":5,"difference":3.82}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":2.4,"shockChange":-6,"controlsMeanChange":-7.78,"controlsMinChange":-10.5,"controlsMaxChange":-4.2,"controls":5,"difference":1.78,"outsideControlRange":false}},{"outcome":"average_weekly_wage","comparison":"percent","baseYear":2022,"controls":[{"geoid":"26031","name":"Cheboygan County, MI","distance":0.312431},{"geoid":"26129","name":"Ogemaw County, MI","distance":0.462236},{"geoid":"26109","name":"Menominee County, MI","distance":0.713975},{"geoid":"26097","name":"Mackinac County, MI","distance":0.7457},{"geoid":"26011","name":"Arenac County, MI","distance":0.768256}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2020,"shockValue":731,"shockChange":-8.050314,"controlsMeanChange":-8.696292,"controlsMinChange":-10.024155,"controlsMaxChange":-8.104575,"controls":5,"difference":0.645977},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2021,"shockValue":766,"shockChange":-3.647799,"controlsMeanChange":-2.999749,"controlsMinChange":-4.648391,"controlsMaxChange":-1.568627,"controls":5,"difference":-0.64805},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2023,"shockValue":833,"shockChange":4.779874,"controlsMeanChange":4.901189,"controlsMinChange":2.979738,"controlsMaxChange":6.227106,"controls":5,"difference":-0.121315},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":877,"shockChange":10.314465,"controlsMeanChange":10.115755,"controlsMinChange":7.320261,"controlsMaxChange":13.164251,"controls":5,"difference":0.198711},{"relativeYear":2,"year":2025,"shockValue":891,"shockChange":12.075472,"controlsMeanChange":17.007005,"controlsMinChange":11.561383,"controlsMaxChange":21.859903,"controls":5,"difference":-4.931534}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":877,"shockChange":10.314465,"controlsMeanChange":10.115755,"controlsMinChange":7.320261,"controlsMaxChange":13.164251,"controls":5,"difference":0.198711,"outsideControlRange":false}},{"outcome":"unemployment_rate","comparison":"points","baseYear":2022,"controls":[{"geoid":"26133","name":"Osceola County, MI","distance":0.356268},{"geoid":"26107","name":"Mecosta County, MI","distance":0.682819},{"geoid":"26063","name":"Huron County, MI","distance":0.729242},{"geoid":"26101","name":"Manistee County, MI","distance":0.7354},{"geoid":"26047","name":"Emmet County, MI","distance":0.842129}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2020,"shockValue":10.1,"shockChange":4.7,"controlsMeanChange":4.88,"controlsMinChange":4.2,"controlsMaxChange":5.5,"controls":5,"difference":-0.18},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2021,"shockValue":5.9,"shockChange":0.5,"controlsMeanChange":0.88,"controlsMinChange":0.6,"controlsMaxChange":1.3,"controls":5,"difference":-0.38},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2023,"shockValue":5.1,"shockChange":-0.3,"controlsMeanChange":0.02,"controlsMinChange":-0.3,"controlsMaxChange":0.5,"controls":5,"difference":-0.32},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":5.3,"shockChange":-0.1,"controlsMeanChange":0.76,"controlsMinChange":0.2,"controlsMaxChange":1.6,"controls":5,"difference":-0.86},{"relativeYear":2,"year":2025,"shockValue":5.7,"shockChange":0.3,"controlsMeanChange":1.32,"controlsMinChange":0.9,"controlsMaxChange":2,"controls":5,"difference":-1.02}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":5.3,"shockChange":-0.1,"controlsMeanChange":0.76,"controlsMinChange":0.2,"controlsMaxChange":1.6,"controls":5,"difference":-0.86,"outsideControlRange":true}},{"outcome":"per_capita_income","comparison":"percent","baseYear":2022,"controls":[{"geoid":"26097","name":"Mackinac County, MI","distance":0.444878},{"geoid":"26063","name":"Huron County, MI","distance":0.735666},{"geoid":"26053","name":"Gogebic County, MI","distance":0.863073},{"geoid":"26133","name":"Osceola County, MI","distance":0.887736},{"geoid":"26009","name":"Antrim County, MI","distance":0.917134}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2020,"shockValue":52268,"shockChange":-8.174487,"controlsMeanChange":-7.52176,"controlsMinChange":-9.279434,"controlsMaxChange":-5.775615,"controls":5,"difference":-0.652728},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2021,"shockValue":54925,"shockChange":-3.506614,"controlsMeanChange":-0.086959,"controlsMinChange":-2.597263,"controlsMaxChange":1.344239,"controls":5,"difference":-3.419656},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2023,"shockValue":60919,"shockChange":7.02377,"controlsMeanChange":6.346959,"controlsMinChange":5.027238,"controlsMaxChange":8.314359,"controls":5,"difference":0.676811},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":63595,"shockChange":11.725022,"controlsMeanChange":11.080419,"controlsMinChange":10.313988,"controlsMaxChange":12.252845,"controls":5,"difference":0.644603}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":63595,"shockChange":11.725022,"controlsMeanChange":11.080419,"controlsMinChange":10.313988,"controlsMaxChange":12.252845,"controls":5,"difference":0.644603,"outsideControlRange":false}}]},{"domain":"contracts-and-grants","geoid":"26019","fiscalYear":2023,"amount":37823766.2,"population":18452,"perResident":2049.846423,"baselinePerResident":350.0394,"baselineYears":2,"ratio":5.856045,"increasePerResident":1699.807023,"nextPerResident":-242.105309,"persisted":false,"topRecipientShare":0.532127,"eligible":true,"exclusionReason":null,"name":"Benzie County, MI","effects":[{"outcome":"job_growth_rate","comparison":"points","baseYear":2022,"controls":[{"geoid":"26097","name":"Mackinac County, MI","distance":1.02594},{"geoid":"26089","name":"Leelanau County, MI","distance":1.310237},{"geoid":"26029","name":"Charlevoix County, MI","distance":1.322538},{"geoid":"26143","name":"Roscommon County, MI","distance":1.4284},{"geoid":"26149","name":"St. Joseph County, MI","distance":1.490795}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2020,"shockValue":-10,"shockChange":-18.4,"controlsMeanChange":-17.16,"controlsMinChange":-20,"controlsMaxChange":-13.1,"controls":5,"difference":-1.24},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2021,"shockValue":9.7,"shockChange":1.3,"controlsMeanChange":-0.8,"controlsMinChange":-3.8,"controlsMaxChange":3.6,"controls":5,"difference":2.1},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2023,"shockValue":1.2,"shockChange":-7.2,"controlsMeanChange":-1.38,"controlsMinChange":-5.1,"controlsMaxChange":8.9,"controls":5,"difference":-5.82},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":2.4,"shockChange":-6,"controlsMeanChange":-5.6,"controlsMinChange":-6.6,"controlsMaxChange":-4.2,"controls":5,"difference":-0.4},{"relativeYear":2,"year":2025,"shockValue":3,"shockChange":-5.4,"controlsMeanChange":-5.6,"controlsMinChange":-11.5,"controlsMaxChange":4.5,"controls":5,"difference":0.2}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":2.4,"shockChange":-6,"controlsMeanChange":-5.6,"controlsMinChange":-6.6,"controlsMaxChange":-4.2,"controls":5,"difference":-0.4,"outsideControlRange":false}},{"outcome":"unemployment_rate","comparison":"points","baseYear":2022,"controls":[{"geoid":"26047","name":"Emmet County, MI","distance":0.552363},{"geoid":"26151","name":"Sanilac County, MI","distance":0.631316},{"geoid":"26063","name":"Huron County, MI","distance":0.637209},{"geoid":"26137","name":"Otsego County, MI","distance":0.762851},{"geoid":"26079","name":"Kalkaska County, MI","distance":0.766485}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2020,"shockValue":10.1,"shockChange":4.7,"controlsMeanChange":5.18,"controlsMinChange":4.8,"controlsMaxChange":5.6,"controls":5,"difference":-0.48},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2021,"shockValue":5.9,"shockChange":0.5,"controlsMeanChange":0.92,"controlsMinChange":0.6,"controlsMaxChange":1.2,"controls":5,"difference":-0.42},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2023,"shockValue":5.1,"shockChange":-0.3,"controlsMeanChange":-0.22,"controlsMinChange":-0.5,"controlsMaxChange":0.2,"controls":5,"difference":-0.08},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":5.3,"shockChange":-0.1,"controlsMeanChange":0.3,"controlsMinChange":0,"controlsMaxChange":0.6,"controls":5,"difference":-0.4},{"relativeYear":2,"year":2025,"shockValue":5.7,"shockChange":0.3,"controlsMeanChange":0.96,"controlsMinChange":0.5,"controlsMaxChange":1.4,"controls":5,"difference":-0.66}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":5.3,"shockChange":-0.1,"controlsMeanChange":0.3,"controlsMinChange":0,"controlsMaxChange":0.6,"controls":5,"difference":-0.4,"outsideControlRange":true}},{"outcome":"median_household_income","comparison":"percent","baseYear":2022,"controls":[{"geoid":"26015","name":"Barry County, MI","distance":0.817553},{"geoid":"26155","name":"Shiawassee County, MI","distance":0.826499},{"geoid":"26137","name":"Otsego County, MI","distance":0.859228},{"geoid":"26101","name":"Manistee County, MI","distance":0.872301},{"geoid":"26029","name":"Charlevoix County, MI","distance":0.879254}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2020,"shockValue":64526,"shockChange":-2.004678,"controlsMeanChange":-4.929899,"controlsMinChange":-6.955928,"controlsMaxChange":-3.484467,"controls":5,"difference":2.925222},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2021,"shockValue":67924,"shockChange":3.155848,"controlsMeanChange":-7.931803,"controlsMinChange":-14.14161,"controlsMaxChange":-2.448555,"controls":5,"difference":11.087651},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2023,"shockValue":65594,"shockChange":-0.382711,"controlsMeanChange":5.34512,"controlsMinChange":2.950455,"controlsMaxChange":9.869398,"controls":5,"difference":-5.727831},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":76215,"shockChange":15.74735,"controlsMeanChange":9.770741,"controlsMinChange":0.255038,"controlsMaxChange":15.126523,"controls":5,"difference":5.976609}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":76215,"shockChange":15.74735,"controlsMeanChange":9.770741,"controlsMinChange":0.255038,"controlsMaxChange":15.126523,"controls":5,"difference":5.976609,"outsideControlRange":true}},{"outcome":"poverty_rate","comparison":"points","baseYear":2022,"controls":[{"geoid":"26047","name":"Emmet County, MI","distance":0.47341},{"geoid":"26079","name":"Kalkaska County, MI","distance":0.509662},{"geoid":"26029","name":"Charlevoix County, MI","distance":0.614146},{"geoid":"26063","name":"Huron County, MI","distance":0.71668},{"geoid":"26101","name":"Manistee County, MI","distance":0.756367}],"path":[{"relativeYear":-3,"year":2020,"shockValue":9.5,"shockChange":-0.4,"controlsMeanChange":-0.28,"controlsMinChange":-0.6,"controlsMaxChange":0,"controls":5,"difference":-0.12},{"relativeYear":-2,"year":2021,"shockValue":9.3,"shockChange":-0.6,"controlsMeanChange":-0.28,"controlsMinChange":-1.4,"controlsMaxChange":0.4,"controls":5,"difference":-0.32},{"relativeYear":0,"year":2023,"shockValue":9.7,"shockChange":-0.2,"controlsMeanChange":1.22,"controlsMinChange":0.4,"controlsMaxChange":2.3,"controls":5,"difference":-1.42},{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":9.2,"shockChange":-0.7,"controlsMeanChange":0.5,"controlsMinChange":-1.2,"controlsMaxChange":2.2,"controls":5,"difference":-1.2}],"headline":{"relativeYear":1,"year":2024,"shockValue":9.2,"shockChange":-0.7,"controlsMeanChange":0.5,"controlsMinChange":-1.2,"controlsMaxChange":2.2,"controls":5,"difference":-1.2,"outsideControlRange":false}}]},{"domain":"transportation-grants","geoid":"26019","fiscalYear":2023,"amount":20107646.49,"population":18452,"perResident":1089.727211,"baselinePerResident":185.136371,"baselineYears":2,"ratio":5.886078,"increasePerResident":904.590839,"nextPerResident":-143.550567,"persisted":false,"topRecipientShare":1,"eligible":false,"exclusionReason":"single-recipient-spike","name":"Benzie County, MI","effects":null}],"caveats":[{"id":"obligations","text":"Money is counted when the government commits it (obligations), not when it is paid out; a multi-year contract can be obligated at once."},{"id":"place-of-performance","text":"Money is placed where the work is performed or the program operates, which is not always where the jobs, workers or beneficiaries are."},{"id":"few-years","text":"Only a few fiscal years of money are loaded (see the coverage), so each comparison follows a place for one or two years after the money at most."},{"id":"small-samples","text":"Some comparisons rest on few places: read the number of places and the uncertainty range with every result."},{"id":"association","text":"These are comparisons, not proof of cause and effect: other events in the same places and years can explain a difference."},{"id":"many-comparisons","text":"Many pairings and years are compared at once: by chance alone, about one clear difference in twenty can appear where there is none."},{"id":"matched-counties","text":"Each place is compared with similar counties in the same Census division that saw no comparable jump in money; similar is not identical."}],"sources":[{"id":"bea-regional","name":"Regional Economic Accounts","publisher":"U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis","attribution":"U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, Personal Income by County (CAINC1) and Regional Price Parities; counties mapped to metro areas with OMB Bulletin 23-01 delineations","homepage":"https://www.bea.gov/data/by-place-county-metro-local","vintage":"2024","loadedAt":"2026-09-30T21:50:03.389Z"},{"id":"bls-laus","name":"Local Area Unemployment Statistics","publisher":"U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics","attribution":"U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Local Area Unemployment Statistics","homepage":"https://www.bls.gov/lau/","vintage":"2025","loadedAt":"2026-09-30T21:51:58.235Z"},{"id":"bls-qcew","name":"Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages","publisher":"U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics","attribution":"U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages","homepage":"https://www.bls.gov/cew/","vintage":"2026 Q1","loadedAt":"2026-09-30T21:54:22.947Z"},{"id":"census-bfs","name":"Business Formation Statistics","publisher":"U.S. Census Bureau","attribution":"U.S. Census Bureau, Business Formation Statistics (county business applications)","homepage":"https://www.census.gov/econ/bfs/","vintage":"2026-10-01","loadedAt":"2026-10-01T15:51:40.026Z"},{"id":"census-bps","name":"Building Permits Survey","publisher":"U.S. Census Bureau","attribution":"U.S. Census Bureau, Building Permits Survey (county files)","homepage":"https://www.census.gov/construction/bps/","vintage":"2026-08","loadedAt":"2026-09-30T22:14:14.060Z"},{"id":"census-geo","name":"Cartographic Boundary Files, Gazetteer and metro delineations","publisher":"U.S. Census Bureau","attribution":"U.S. Census Bureau, Cartographic Boundary Files and Gazetteer Files; OMB metropolitan and micropolitan statistical area delineations; American Community Survey 5-year population (city and county shares)","homepage":"https://www.census.gov/geographies/mapping-files/time-series/geo/cartographic-boundary.html","vintage":"2025","loadedAt":"2026-10-01T07:50:40.343Z"},{"id":"census-pep","name":"Population Estimates Program","publisher":"U.S. Census Bureau","attribution":"U.S. Census Bureau, Population Estimates Program","homepage":"https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/popest.html","vintage":"2025","loadedAt":"2026-09-30T22:05:38.461Z"},{"id":"census-sahie","name":"Small Area Health Insurance Estimates","publisher":"U.S. Census Bureau","attribution":"U.S. Census Bureau, Small Area Health Insurance Estimates (SAHIE)","homepage":"https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/sahie.html","vintage":"2024","loadedAt":"2026-09-29T09:23:29.353Z"},{"id":"census-saipe","name":"Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates","publisher":"U.S. Census Bureau","attribution":"U.S. Census Bureau, Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates (SAIPE)","homepage":"https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/saipe.html","vintage":"2024","loadedAt":"2026-09-29T09:23:19.832Z"},{"id":"usaspending-assistance","name":"Federal financial assistance transactions (Financial Assistance Broker Submission)","publisher":"U.S. Department of the Treasury, USAspending.gov","attribution":"USAspending.gov, prime award financial assistance transactions (FABS)","homepage":"https://www.usaspending.gov/download_center/award_data_archive","vintage":"2026-10-06","loadedAt":"2026-10-06T00:44:53.593Z"},{"id":"usaspending-contracts","name":"Federal contract transactions (Federal Procurement Data System)","publisher":"U.S. Department of the Treasury, USAspending.gov","attribution":"USAspending.gov, prime award contract transactions (FPDS)","homepage":"https://www.usaspending.gov/download_center/award_data_archive","vintage":"2026-10-06","loadedAt":"2026-10-06T00:40:38.183Z"},{"id":"zillow","name":"Zillow Home Value Index, Observed Rent Index and affordability","publisher":"Zillow Research","attribution":"Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI), Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI) and Zillow affordability data, Zillow Research, zillow.com/research/data","homepage":"https://www.zillow.com/research/data/","vintage":"2026-08","loadedAt":"2026-09-30T22:06:10.720Z"}]}